| When Still: The Ritual | |||||||
| Location | Item | ||||||
| Outside | Starting point | 2 water arrows in water | 2 x Silver Nuggets @ 100 ea | ||||
| Outside | Starting point | 1 rope arrow in footlocker | Purse | ||||
| 1st Floor | Kitchen | 1 Relic of Water in room under grate | |||||
| 1st Floor | Meditation stairwell | 1 Gathering Key on corpse | |||||
| 1st Floor | Meditation stairwell | 1 broadhead arrow in corpse | |||||
| 1st Floor | Meditation stairwell | 1 healing potion on floor | |||||
| 1st Floor | Meditation stairwell | 1 Crypt Key on rack | |||||
| 1st Floor | Corridor north of chapel | 1 "Bedroom Key" on Hammerite | |||||
| 1st Floor | Crypt - 1st room north of entrance | 1 Rusty Key in room beneath sarcophagus | |||||
| 1st Floor | Crypt - small room west of corridor | 1 pair Jonas' glasses | |||||
| 1st Floor | Crypt - small room west of corridor | 1 Bell Tower Key | |||||
| 1st Floor | Foyer inside main entrance and south of Herbs | 1 "For Captain James" scroll on guard | |||||
| Outside | Herb shed | 3 healing fruit in plant beds | |||||
| Outside | Herb shed | 2 water arrows in basin | |||||
| Outside | Herb shed | 1 Relic of Fire in room under grate | |||||
| Outside | Garden | 3 water arrows in fountain | |||||
| Basement | Wine Cellar - lower level | 4 moss arrows under arch | |||||
| Basement | Wine Cellar - lower level secret room | 1 rosary in chest | |||||
| Basement | Wine Cellar - upper level secret room | 1 healing potion on shelf | |||||
| Basement | Wine Cellar - upper level secret room | 2 wedges cheese on table | |||||
| 2nd Floor | North bedroom off corridor south of chapel | 1 healing potion on table | |||||
| 2nd Floor | South bedroom off corridor north of chapel | 1 healing potion in chest | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Secret study | 1 Brother Jonas's Room Key | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Secret study (after ritual is complete) | 1 Small Key on ghost | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Brother Jonas' room | 1 "The Ritual" scroll in attic under floorboards | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Brother Jonas' room | 1 invisibility potion in attic under floorboards | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Chamber with Brother Larry's corpse | 1 Relic of All Sins in room under grate | |||||
| 2nd Floor | Pantry northeast of Brother Larry's corpse | 2 water arrows in basin | |||||
| 3rd Floor | Brother Samuel's room | 1 Secret Study Key in wall niche | |||||
| 4th Floor | Balcony study | 1 "St. Mary's Orphanage" book on table | |||||